The Warhammer 40k UK Grand Tournament was held this weekend at Warhammer World. The top ten, via Prophaniti on The Warhammer Forum and Mad Larkn on Warseer, were:
1: Ugo Oliveti, Eldar (Seer council on bikes)
2: Di Tomaso, CSM (double lash, 5 oblits, LR with zerkers, plague marine and MoD marines )
3: Urban Knight, CSM (2 lash, 4 oblits and Land raiding berzerkers)
4: torgoch, Eldar (2 Seer Council Eldar)
5: Scott Young, Orks (4 Battlewagon + Ghazgul)
6: James Mcglough, CSM (Chaos, Abbadon, Kharne and 2 Land raiders)
7: Phil Walter, Tyranids (Nidzilla)
8: Gary Percival, Orks
9: Falces Imperatoris, Witchunters (canoness, priest and celestians packing 3 eviserators and with double flamers) in a rhino, Two Rhino mounted sisters squads packing double flamers, One Foot sisters squad with double meltas, A little squad of 5 seraphim with inferno pistols, 2 exorcists, A squadron of 2 Penny engines)
10: SpikyDavid, Orks (4 trucks of boys, a warboss, a mek, and several squadrons of buggies)
Out of the top 50 there were:
14 Orks
12 Eldar
7 Chaos
4 Daemons
2 Witch hunters
2 Tyranids
2 Space marines
2 Space wolves
1 Necron
1 Blood angel
1 Dark eldar
1 Guard
1 Tau
Here's the link to the full results sheet.
Monday, March 16, 2009
Sunday, March 15, 2009
OPINION: On rules
This is a bit of a mixed bag of a blog entry. The main meat of my post is an opinion piece/rant about rules and rules lawyering and can be found below.
First up though, thanks to everyone who made comments regarding my Assault squad, they are all much appreciated! I feel like I am getting into my stride with painting my Blood Angels infantry and I look forward to painting more. It's almost enough to stop me from moving on to the Orks once I reach the 2000 point mark for the Warseer pledge. Perhaps I should plough on with the Blood Angels until I've painted the lot?
Anyway, that's a decision I won't have to make for a few months yet.
The completion of my Assault squad adds 10 points to my painting score for the year. Rather than keep track of the score in individual blog entries I've added some text to the column on the right so it will be there for all to see at all times. My total for the year is now 30 points and with a quarter of the year almost gone I'm on track to beat my target of 100 points for the year.
On a kind of related note I'll be taking off some of those widgets on the side of the blog for a while. I've been having some technical difficulties with my blog so I need to find out the source of the problem and I suspect one of the add-ons is causing Firefox to crash.
So finally we come to the main topic of this blog entry. I've written up another 5th edition game I played using my Daemonhunters and Imperial Guard against Gary's Chaos Daemons. The game threw up a few interesting rules issues which allowed me to rant about wider rules issues at the end of the battle report. I've reproduced this discussion topic here in the hopes that I get some useful advice.
Just in case you haven't read the report this was all sparked by an incident where I shot through the edge of a wood. If you go to page 22 of your 40k 5th rulebook the unit I shot at was in the same position as marine C in the diagram, behind a wood but beyond the furthest tree meaning it got no cover save.
We also had a problem with the Changelings' rules which state that it can pick an enemy unit within 24" when it shoots and force it to make a Leadership test. If the unit fails it shoots at it's own units. For a 5 point upgrade it seems clear that this shouldn't apply to EVERY unit within 24" every turn but the rules are written poorly and don't rule this out.
On rules
The forest LOS/cover save and Changeling issues were perfect examples of the problems I have playing games against my regular opponents.
I read the rulebooks when I buy them, read the army codex, read White Dwarf, print out the FAQ's, check out online forums and listen to podcasts . My opponents don't. That means I am usually well informed about potential rules issues before they come up while my opponents aren't.
Most of the time I shy away from contentious units when I'm building my armies, and/or discuss them with my opponents in advance. I also 'pull my shots' on the tabletop and usually take the weaker option when a possibly arguable rule presents itself. I usually let my opponents get away with minor rules infringements during the game rather than pull them up on every little thing. This means I often feel like I'm playing a kind of 'ghost' version of the game with one hand tied behind my back.
By the same token my opponents must get frustrated when they play against me because every now and then I'll reference a rule that they are completely unaware of. Then they will point out that several games ago we played differently. That's usually because I didn't think it was a game breaking moment at the time and therefore not worth pointing out, because a new FAQ has been released, a codex is reprinted or rules are 'clarified' in White Dwarf, or maybe just because I thought they understood the rule and it was tight but I couldn't be bothered to argue about it.
In the LOS issue we had in the game that sparked this debate I probably wouldn't have gone for the shot if my shooting unit was decent in close combat. If the unit had been a Terminator squad instead of an Imperial Guard I would have shot at something else or otherwise fudged the issue to not create a problem. Similarly, if I was winning or losing heavily I might not have taken the shot, just because it wouldn't have affected the outcome of the game.
My opponents are probably coming to the issue from the point of view of precedence; they play the game the way they played last time without any in between reading of the rules or seeking out of FAQs and such. If it was good in the last five games why should it suddenly change now? From my opponent's point of view these inconsistencies might seem like rules-lawyering or worse, outright cheating.
When I got back into Warhammer fantasy I tried a different tack by trying to get the rules perfect during every game. I thought if we could nail things early there would be no problem later but that doesn't work either. Our games slow down to a crawl and I still feel bad about winning a game because my opponent didn't fully understand the rules rather than through a clever strategy or tactic.
It's like we're playing the same game but at two different levels.
Here's the question: is that my problem or is it up to my opponent to learn the rules?
Maybe I should just be a bit tougher, press my knowledge advantage and take the wins? Then the ball is back in my opponent's court and it's up to them to either put the effort into learning the game or continually get beat.
Or maybe I should just loosen up and play rough and ready with the rules, turning a blind eye to rules infringements and taking the hits when they come. It is just a game after all, a way to wind down after a tough day at work. Why should I get so worked up about something so minor?
I really don't know.
Does anyone have any thoughts? How does your group play? What is your rules level?
First up though, thanks to everyone who made comments regarding my Assault squad, they are all much appreciated! I feel like I am getting into my stride with painting my Blood Angels infantry and I look forward to painting more. It's almost enough to stop me from moving on to the Orks once I reach the 2000 point mark for the Warseer pledge. Perhaps I should plough on with the Blood Angels until I've painted the lot?
Anyway, that's a decision I won't have to make for a few months yet.
The completion of my Assault squad adds 10 points to my painting score for the year. Rather than keep track of the score in individual blog entries I've added some text to the column on the right so it will be there for all to see at all times. My total for the year is now 30 points and with a quarter of the year almost gone I'm on track to beat my target of 100 points for the year.
On a kind of related note I'll be taking off some of those widgets on the side of the blog for a while. I've been having some technical difficulties with my blog so I need to find out the source of the problem and I suspect one of the add-ons is causing Firefox to crash.
So finally we come to the main topic of this blog entry. I've written up another 5th edition game I played using my Daemonhunters and Imperial Guard against Gary's Chaos Daemons. The game threw up a few interesting rules issues which allowed me to rant about wider rules issues at the end of the battle report. I've reproduced this discussion topic here in the hopes that I get some useful advice.
Just in case you haven't read the report this was all sparked by an incident where I shot through the edge of a wood. If you go to page 22 of your 40k 5th rulebook the unit I shot at was in the same position as marine C in the diagram, behind a wood but beyond the furthest tree meaning it got no cover save.
We also had a problem with the Changelings' rules which state that it can pick an enemy unit within 24" when it shoots and force it to make a Leadership test. If the unit fails it shoots at it's own units. For a 5 point upgrade it seems clear that this shouldn't apply to EVERY unit within 24" every turn but the rules are written poorly and don't rule this out.
On rules
The forest LOS/cover save and Changeling issues were perfect examples of the problems I have playing games against my regular opponents.
I read the rulebooks when I buy them, read the army codex, read White Dwarf, print out the FAQ's, check out online forums and listen to podcasts . My opponents don't. That means I am usually well informed about potential rules issues before they come up while my opponents aren't.
Most of the time I shy away from contentious units when I'm building my armies, and/or discuss them with my opponents in advance. I also 'pull my shots' on the tabletop and usually take the weaker option when a possibly arguable rule presents itself. I usually let my opponents get away with minor rules infringements during the game rather than pull them up on every little thing. This means I often feel like I'm playing a kind of 'ghost' version of the game with one hand tied behind my back.
By the same token my opponents must get frustrated when they play against me because every now and then I'll reference a rule that they are completely unaware of. Then they will point out that several games ago we played differently. That's usually because I didn't think it was a game breaking moment at the time and therefore not worth pointing out, because a new FAQ has been released, a codex is reprinted or rules are 'clarified' in White Dwarf, or maybe just because I thought they understood the rule and it was tight but I couldn't be bothered to argue about it.
In the LOS issue we had in the game that sparked this debate I probably wouldn't have gone for the shot if my shooting unit was decent in close combat. If the unit had been a Terminator squad instead of an Imperial Guard I would have shot at something else or otherwise fudged the issue to not create a problem. Similarly, if I was winning or losing heavily I might not have taken the shot, just because it wouldn't have affected the outcome of the game.
My opponents are probably coming to the issue from the point of view of precedence; they play the game the way they played last time without any in between reading of the rules or seeking out of FAQs and such. If it was good in the last five games why should it suddenly change now? From my opponent's point of view these inconsistencies might seem like rules-lawyering or worse, outright cheating.
When I got back into Warhammer fantasy I tried a different tack by trying to get the rules perfect during every game. I thought if we could nail things early there would be no problem later but that doesn't work either. Our games slow down to a crawl and I still feel bad about winning a game because my opponent didn't fully understand the rules rather than through a clever strategy or tactic.
It's like we're playing the same game but at two different levels.
Here's the question: is that my problem or is it up to my opponent to learn the rules?
Maybe I should just be a bit tougher, press my knowledge advantage and take the wins? Then the ball is back in my opponent's court and it's up to them to either put the effort into learning the game or continually get beat.
Or maybe I should just loosen up and play rough and ready with the rules, turning a blind eye to rules infringements and taking the hits when they come. It is just a game after all, a way to wind down after a tough day at work. Why should I get so worked up about something so minor?
I really don't know.
Does anyone have any thoughts? How does your group play? What is your rules level?
Friday, March 13, 2009
PAINTING: Ten bad Ass marines
I've finally completed my Assault squad, taken some half decent photos and put them forward for the Warseer Tale of 40k painters painting pledge.
I've already described how I painted the models in an earlier blog entry so I'll just let the pictures do the talking now.

All the models painted for the pledge so far - 1035 points
I've already described how I painted the models in an earlier blog entry so I'll just let the pictures do the talking now.
All the models painted for the pledge so far - 1035 points
Cast out the daemon...
The eagled eyed among you may have spotted that I posted up a battle report on my other blog yesterday. It was my first game of 40k 5th edition using my Imperial Guard and Daemonhunters. If you voted that I use these armies for the next few months then you might want to read on here.
The eagled eyed among you may have spotted that I posted up a battle report on my other blog yesterday. It was my first game of 40k 5th edition using my Imperial Guard and Daemonhunters. If you voted that I use these armies for the next few months then you might want to read on here.
Monday, March 9, 2009
NEWS AND RUMOURS: Go Guard
40K
Games Workshop have given us further confirmation of the new Imperial Guard codex on their website. There are really nice photos of the new Cadian command squad, Catachan command squad, Lord Commissar, Primaris Psyker, Master of Ordnance, Officer of the Fleet, Astropath and Ratlings.
While I'm not convinced by the Ratlings just yet I love the rest. I'm even considering adding to my Catachans due to the likes of the model below.
He looks like one tough hombre!
And in other news... a battle report
As I mentioned in my previous post I will be blogging my last three 40k 5th edition battle reports over the course of the week. My first was my last with Blood Angels for a while. Would they go out with a bang against the Chaos Daemons? Find out here.
Games Workshop have given us further confirmation of the new Imperial Guard codex on their website. There are really nice photos of the new Cadian command squad, Catachan command squad, Lord Commissar, Primaris Psyker, Master of Ordnance, Officer of the Fleet, Astropath and Ratlings.
While I'm not convinced by the Ratlings just yet I love the rest. I'm even considering adding to my Catachans due to the likes of the model below.
And in other news... a battle report
As I mentioned in my previous post I will be blogging my last three 40k 5th edition battle reports over the course of the week. My first was my last with Blood Angels for a while. Would they go out with a bang against the Chaos Daemons? Find out here.
Friday, March 6, 2009
GENERAL: Today will be a day of battle!
I have a few hours spare, and while I'm tempted to push on with my painting I'm going to spend that time catching up with my battle reports.
I've just posted up another 4th edition Imperial Guard game over on my other blog. This was a 1500 point game against a newbie Space Marine player.
Mainly though, I will be writing up my last three games of 5th edition 40k. One was played with my Blood Angels and the following two were games using my Imperial Guard and Daemonhunters. I have photos for all of them, providing I can find them on my laptop, and hopefully they should jog a few memories of in-game events.
I'll blog the completed battle reports over the coming week.
If I have any spare time after that I plan to photograph my Assault Squad properly for the Warseer painting pledge, finish off modelling my Dreadnought and then write up a 1500 point list for future Imperial Guard and Daemonhunter games.
I've just posted up another 4th edition Imperial Guard game over on my other blog. This was a 1500 point game against a newbie Space Marine player.
Mainly though, I will be writing up my last three games of 5th edition 40k. One was played with my Blood Angels and the following two were games using my Imperial Guard and Daemonhunters. I have photos for all of them, providing I can find them on my laptop, and hopefully they should jog a few memories of in-game events.
I'll blog the completed battle reports over the coming week.
If I have any spare time after that I plan to photograph my Assault Squad properly for the Warseer painting pledge, finish off modelling my Dreadnought and then write up a 1500 point list for future Imperial Guard and Daemonhunter games.
Monday, March 2, 2009
NEWS AND RUMOURS: Eeeew!
Forge World
The big news on my radar over the past week was the Forge World preview of Nurgle Daemon Prince Mamon and his herald.
My understanding is that Mamon was one of the closest advisers to Cardinal Xaphan during the Siege of Vraks and by the time of the third book, due out this year, has grown in power to become a Nurgle Daemon Prince.
Opinion is divided on this model but I love it. It's nice to see a Daemon Prince model without a big Space Marine influence. Plus he's huge! Check out the size compared to a regular Plague Marine below.
One of the cool features it's easy to miss is the pus cauldron on the model's back in which Nurglings are chilling out, as if it is a hot tub. Hilarious.

Sadly, it's extremely unlikely I'll ever buy this model. I'm buying no models this year at all, and I have no plans to collect a Nurgle Chaos army.
Forge World have also announced their open day which will take place on Sunday 5th April at Warhammer World. There is no charge for admission. Stuff on show will include Imperial Armour Volume Seven - The Siege of Vraks Part 3, some previously unseen Chaos and Ork models, and the new show only model.
The big news on my radar over the past week was the Forge World preview of Nurgle Daemon Prince Mamon and his herald.
Opinion is divided on this model but I love it. It's nice to see a Daemon Prince model without a big Space Marine influence. Plus he's huge! Check out the size compared to a regular Plague Marine below.
Sadly, it's extremely unlikely I'll ever buy this model. I'm buying no models this year at all, and I have no plans to collect a Nurgle Chaos army.
Forge World have also announced their open day which will take place on Sunday 5th April at Warhammer World. There is no charge for admission. Stuff on show will include Imperial Armour Volume Seven - The Siege of Vraks Part 3, some previously unseen Chaos and Ork models, and the new show only model.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
PAINTING AND MODELLING: Complete Ass
The Blood Angels Assault Squad is complete!
I've been very busy at work this week, finishing late and working six days, so my free time was severely restricted. I had a direct choice to make between updating my blog and painting my models. I went for the models.
I took a leaf out of my own book and painted in short bursts each night. One night I finished the Sergeant's power sword. The next I highlighted the helmets. On the third night I detailed the helmets. The fourth I highlighted the jump pack harnesses and weapons. Next I painted the barbed wire and added it to the bases. The plasma pistols came next. Today I painted the melta-bomb on the Sergeant.
Individually, each step seems insignificant but by doing a task each day at least I felt like I was making progress. And here I am with a finished unit.
So with the Assault Squad done I began to put together my Dreadnought.
It's the Dread from the Assault on Black Reach boxed set. I already own a Blood Angel specific Dreadnought armed with a multi-melta and storm bolter so I decided I would hack up this plastic version to give it an Assault cannon and heavy flamer. You can see from the photo that so far I have removed the multi-melta barrels and replaced them with an assault cannon from an old Baal predator. My next task will be to detail the rest of the arm with an ammo feed and something to disguise the multi-melta ammunition.
Going berzerk
I've written up another battle report from 40k 4th edition involving my Imperial Guard. It was a 1500 point games against Gary's Khorne Berzerker Chaos Space Marine army. It was a bit of an experiment for me as I tried out the drop troops doctrine for the first time.
I took a leaf out of my own book and painted in short bursts each night. One night I finished the Sergeant's power sword. The next I highlighted the helmets. On the third night I detailed the helmets. The fourth I highlighted the jump pack harnesses and weapons. Next I painted the barbed wire and added it to the bases. The plasma pistols came next. Today I painted the melta-bomb on the Sergeant.
Individually, each step seems insignificant but by doing a task each day at least I felt like I was making progress. And here I am with a finished unit.
So with the Assault Squad done I began to put together my Dreadnought.
Going berzerk
I've written up another battle report from 40k 4th edition involving my Imperial Guard. It was a 1500 point games against Gary's Khorne Berzerker Chaos Space Marine army. It was a bit of an experiment for me as I tried out the drop troops doctrine for the first time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)